Pat Harty just published a post on Hawk Central titled "Pat Harty: Landing in-state recruits not as easy as it used to be" (yeah, his name is in the title...) about Iowa only holding 3 commitments (Jon Winsnieski, Trevon Young and Ike Boettger) from the 9 in-state players that currently hold Iowa offers. Sure, 3 for 9 sounds bad, but 4 of those players are part of the 2014 class, so still probably about a year away from making their college choices. I have no idea why they were included. So anyway, the real number we should be worrying about here is 3 of 5. Now, 3 of 5 doesn't sound so bad. 60%. Is recruiting in-state really any harder than it used to be?
I'm not sure what time frame Harty is using when he says, "All I’m saying is that I can’t remember when so many in-state recruits held Iowa offers without committing." He does mention Hayden Fry at one point, but I'm going to use the past 12 years since that is the data that's available on Rivals.com. In that time, Iowa has offered a scholarship to 76 in-state players and 56 of them committed to the Hawkeyes. So that's about 74%. Not too shabby.